The Greatest Identity Theft Story | William Woods’ Real Life Fraud

This week, on Scams, Hacks, and Frauds, I have the most insane Idenity Fraud story to tell you… It is infuriating just to think about and Just when you think it can’t get worse, it does. It’s a story that lasted three decades, and it will make you want to be more protective of your personal information. We’ll share some tips on preventing identity theft and spotting identity theft when it happens using your credit report at the end. That’s this episode of the podcast that helps keep your family safe from Scams, Hacks, and Frauds.
So, before we start, this is a real story, and if you enjoy it, can you please share it with those you care about so we can help keep them safe from Scams, Hacks, and Frauds.
How Identity Fraud Starts
So, this is the story of two men, Matthew David Keirns and William Woods. Their story starts at a hot dog cart in Albuquerque, New Mexico, in 1988… where William and Matthew were working together. William had been there for three years, and Matthew was a new start who’d run away from home at 16 and was travelling the country, using not exactly legal means. One day, William’s wallet went missing. William confronted David, and after threatening to punch him in the face, Matthew eventually returned the wallet… William checked the wallet, and his Social Security card and birth certificate were still inside, so he didn’t think twice about it.
Yet by 1990, Matthew would stop being Matthew completely and become William.
This is perhaps the most extreme case of Identity theft that you can get. Most times, identity theft is just taking someone’s details and using them for a quick benefit, like taking out a loan or an insurance policy… Not stealing someone’s entire life.
So at this point, it’s going to be easy to mix up who’s who: Matthew is going by the name William, and later the real William is going to be forced to use Matthew’s identity. So when we’re talking about the Victim, William Woods, we’ll call him Real William, and when we’re talking about the guy who stole William’s identity, we’ll call him Fraudster Mathew.
For the next few years, there wasn’t much overlap between the two. Real William left New Mexico for El Paso, and after a stint working as a day labourer, got a job in Las Vegas at a Laundromat. At one point was arrested for forgery in 1995, but ended up in Southern California. He worked in a Tech job in San Diego, and moved to Santa Monica in 2009… At that point he was Living in Hotels and motels, selling gemstones, Gold Scraps and anything else he could find in the streets of LA’s jewellery district. Essentially, he was homeless.
Lets flip over to Fraudster Matthew. In December 1990, Fraudster Matthew got a Colorado ID card, and a Job at a Fast Food Restaurant, and a new bank account. A year later, he bought a car with a check that bounced… and an arrest warrant was issued for William, but nothing seems to have come from that.
In 1994, Fraudster Matthew got married, as William Woods, and had a child, with the child taking the surname Woods…
In 2012, Fraudster Matthew was stopped for driving without a Driver’s license, so with help from Ancestry.com, he was able to get a copy of Real William’s birth certificate and applied for a Driver’s License in Wisconsin under the name William David Woods. Fraudster Matthew was also able to get a job at the University of Iowa Hospital using these fake documents. He worked there for about 10 years, remotely, whilst continuing to take out loans in William Woods’ name.
How the Identity Fraud was uncovered
But the two could not remain separate forever. In 2015, Real William had built up a friendship with a YouTuber called Yousef Saleh Erakat, or FouseyTube. Fousey would give him money for food and a place to stay, and in 2019 helped him run a credit report. He was shocked to learn that someone had been opening accounts in his name… So he went to a bank branch in Los Angeles to try to make it stop. He had his ID, so this should be simple, shouldn’t it?
Well, no, Real William doesn’t know the security answers on the account…. So the Bank calls Fraudster Matthew, who tells the bank he’s not in California and that the guy in the bank is a Fraudster… So the police were called.
If you’re thinking now “Great, the police will investigate and sort this out”. I told you that this is the most infuriating, most astounding story you’ve ever heard… and it wouldn’t be that if the police did that. Real William was arrested, charged, and faced trial… and what’s worse, it wasn’t even under his own name… The Police and courts insisted that Real William was, in fact, Matthew….. Real William offered to call his relatives, and the owner of the Albuquerque hot dog cart… But the police were unmoved… And Fraudster Matthew was there to pile on, describing his victim as a “Wrongdoer whose own conduct should mitigate any sympathy felt for him”.
The courts and the public defender were no better for Real William. His own lawyer did not believe him and sent him to be mentally assessed. He was ruled mentally incompetent to stand trial, and sent to a Psyiatric hospital. He was given Psychotropic drugs. He spent 147 days in that hospital, and another 428 days in Jail.
Real William, still identified as Matthew, eventually came to a no-contest plea with the state of California, which allowed him to escape further time in Jail. But despite the whole world telling him that he was crazy and that he was not the real William, real William went on a crusade to take his life back and get justice… With Fraudster Matthew filing police reports to try to keep Real William under control. Real William tried the police where Fraudster Matthew was living – Hartland, Wisconsin- but Fraudster Matthew managed to convince them that Real William was a fraud, and that he was, in fact, William.
Will there be any end to Real William’s nightmare?
A new detective looks into the Identity Theft
We now fast forward to early 2023, and we add a new character to the mix… Ian Mallory. Ian is a detective at the University of Iowa police department, and he’s talking to Fraudster Matthew. Real William has discovered that Fraudster Matthew works at the University of Iowa’s hospital as a remote IT worker… and Fraudster Matthew had been in contact with the University to make complaints that Fraudster Matthew was, well, a Fraudster.
Speaking about the time, Ian Mallory said he felt bad for Fraudster Matthew. Fraudster Matthew had a lot of Identity theft protections in place to keep his story alive, and Mallory was initially convinced that Real William was some professional con man… but during the conversation, Fraudster Matthew was pessimistic about whether or not Mallory could do anything… Which gave Mallory the drive to look into the case deeply. So instead of simply going with the California courts, or throwing it in the too hard basket, he decided to look deeply into the claims.
Eventually, that led him to a check fraud case in North Carolina, but being so old, the case hadn’t been put into the computer system… So he called the police department where the case was investigated, and asked for a copy of the Polaroid mug shot taken of the person arrested.
The response he got back was “What’s a Polaroid?”
Not to be deterred, Mallory asked to speak to the oldest person there and eventually was able to get the Polaroid photo…. And this was the first rock in the Avalanche that would eventually bury Fraudster Matthew… because that photo, and the name on the file, was Real William’s.
That caused Mallory to look closer at the Birth certificates provided by the two men. Real William was, of course, able to provide his birth certificate, and so was Fraudster Matthew… But two things about Fraudster Matthew’s Birth Certificate stood out… one, it was a reprint from 2012. In contrast, Real William’s was original… and all the birth certificates said William Donald Woods, but Fraudster Matthew was going by William David Woods.
So Mallory decided to call William’s parents, surely they would know which William was which. William Woods’ mother had passed, but William Woods’ father was still alive, in Kentucky. Over some long conversations, William’s father confirmed that his son lived in California, that they talked regularly, and that he was able to pick his actual son out of a photo lineup. But it wasn’t quite enough to close the case… If Real William was a fraudster, maybe he had convinced an older man that he was his son…. But there’s one thing that does not lie…. DNA. DNA from Real William and Mr Woods was taken to the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation… and on 19 June 2023, Mallory finally knew for sure what Real William, Mr Woods, you, and even Fraudster Matthew knew… Real William was indeed Real William.
This then led the Iowa Department of Public Safety’s Division of Intelligence to do a deep dive into Fraudster Matthew… and along with hundreds of documents relating to William Woods, there was a reference to an additional FBI file… just a note of a number, nothing more. A thread that was easy to miss, but a thread that, when pulled, led to a 1987 Forgery case and a criminal trespass case… For Matthew David Keirans.
Mallory pulled the file for the Forgery case; the fingerprints and mugshot were definitely not Real William’s. They were Fraudster Matthew.
All the while that Mallory was completing this investigation, however, Fraudster Matthew was continuing to contact him and the LAPD, trying to get Real William Arrested.
Okay, so you cracked a 30-year-old identity fraud case; what are you going to do about it?
Much of the identity theft was too old to charge… and the Identity theft itself didn’t occur in Iowa. Other jurisdictions were also reluctant to bring charges… So Mallory again had to dig deep.
They discovered that earlier that year, Fraudster Matthew had been stopped by the police and provided William’s Birth Certificate and name. That was fresh enough that he could be held by police next time he was in Iowa – remember, he’s a remote worker living in Wisconsin…. And he would be back on Monday 17 July. That gave Mallory a weekend to secure warrants for Fraudster Matthew’s DNA and Fingerprints, and get Wisconsin police to do the same for Mallory’s car and home…
But what name to put on the warrant? We know Fraudster Matthew is not William Woods, but Mallory can’t be sure he’s actually Matthew Keirns… So he filed them under John Doe… and at 3:30 pm on Monday 17 July, the fake William Woods was arrested, photographed, and fingerprinted…
Mallory began to interrogate the man who they arrested – he had been booked under the name William Woods.
The Interrogation lasted six hours, going through every element, Fraudster Matthew still insisted he was William, and that Real William was Crazy and should be locked up. So Mallory brought up William’s father, and on his first go, Fraufdster Matthew got William Woods’ father’s name wrong, and claimed his father was an alcoholic and abused him … But Mallory had met Mr Woods. He knew none of that was true, and that William Woods had a normal upbringing in a fairly wealthy household with private schools and computers at a time when such things were fairly uncommon.
After many hours of dancing around the issues, Mallory confronted Fraudster Matthew with the DNA Evidence… Telling Fraudster Matthew, “They are related; you are not. The father on the birth certificate you gave me has seen photos; he doesn’t know who you are…. Who are you?”
To which Fraudster Matthew replied, “My life is over, isn’t it? My name is Matthew Keirns”. And the photographs and Mugshot proved it.

My life is over, isn’t it? My name is Matthew Keirns
Undoing 30 years of Identity Fraud
So Mallory got to break the news to real William that Fraudster Matthew was in Custody. William’s reply is about as low-key as it could be. He’s quoted as saying, “Cool, I told you so. No one believed me”.
But Mallory’s work wasn’t done. He contacted the Los Angeles County DA to get Real Williams previous sentence vacated, but they insisted that they had the right man and refused to vacate it.
In August 2023, Fraudster Matthew plead guilty to unlawful use of a birth certificate and then obtaining insurance documents under a false name. The Federal Government then got involved, and indicted him on felony charges of making a false statement to a Credit union and aggravated identity theft, which he plead guilty to in April 2024
This then caused a reporter to contact the LA DA and the LAPD, and only then were they moved to vacate the false conviction against Real William.
On 31 January 2025, Fraudster Matthew was sentenced to 12 years in prison, had to pay a fine of $10,000, and restitution to Woods, which at that point he’d paid a mere $6000, and the state of California has paid $80,000 to Real William as compensation, which frankly, is pathetic.
Real William isn’t Fraudster Matthews only victim – There’s no word on what that means for the person Fraudster Matthew married as William, or their child, having been lied to for decades.
How can you protect yourself from Identity Fraud
A lot of countries have data protection laws, and a principle that comes up a lot in these is data minimization; you should only collect just enough data that you need to do the job. When it comes to identity theft and identity fraud, minimizing the amount of personal information you carry can help reduce your risk. We’re not blaming real William here, but a question my wife asked when I told her the story was: Why did William have his birth certificate and Social Security card on him? Carry with you only the ID documents you need, and keep the rest somewhere safe—ideally in a fireproof safe. Also, store enough documents in there to rebuild your identity if needed. Hopefully, you’ll never need it, but if you do, having these documents can be crucial in resolving identity theft or identity fraud cases, assuming the police will look at them.
Anything you don’t need, you should be shredding. Dumpster diving is a thing, and a lot can be learned about you from what you throw out…. So don’t make it easy. Unless you’re someone particularly notable, criminals are opportunists; if someone else is an easier target, that’s where they will go.
Now I want to talk about the piece of evidence that alerted Real William to the problem: credit checking and credit reports. Monitoring your credit reports is one of the best ways to catch identity theft and identity fraud early. In the US, UK, and many other countries, there are three main credit reporting agencies: TransUnion, Equifax, and Experian. Don’t worry too much about the credit score part that they promote heavily; it’s the actual report you need to review for unfamiliar accounts or errors.
You do need to be checking all three. Not all companies report to all three, so by only checking one or two, you’re not getting the full picture.
Many services and sites offer free access to your credit report, and data protection laws often require agencies to provide a copy upon request. Some sites even send you alerts when something changes, helping you spot potential identity fraud fast. If you need help finding these reports, we have resources and links on our website at ScamsHacksandFrauds.com, and in the show notes.
I’ve been Cee, and this has been Scams, Hacks and Frauds. Have you been the victim of Identity Theft? Please reach out, whether it’s just to chat, or so we can see if we can feature your story. You’ll find a link to that in the show notes, and on camsHacksandFrauds.com.
Sources and Further Reading
University of Iowa Stories – UI detective unravels identity theft scheme
Washington Post – Decades-long identity theft scheme sent victim to jail and mental hospital
National Registry of Exonerations – William Woods
Los Angeles Times – Judge vacates conviction of man whose identity was stolen in ‘Kafkaesque’ case
AP – Identity thief whose deception led to his victim’s incarceration gets a 12-year prison term
KCCI – Former University of Iowa hospital worker sentenced for identity theft scheme
